Addressing Disparities in Computer Science Access: Potential Impact of Proposed Bill
Photo by Allison Shelley for EDUimages
Assembly Bill 2097 is a crucial piece of legislation that aims to address the disparities in computer science access across California. The bill, introduced by Assemblymember Marc Berman, requires every public high school in the state to teach a computer science course. According to Berman, the lack of access to computer science education disproportionately affects underserved communities, including Black and brown communities, as well as rural areas. By mandating the teaching of computer science in all public high schools, the bill seeks to bridge the gap and increase access to this critical field of study, as already done in 30 other states.
Currently, Assembly Bill 2097 is in the Senate Appropriations Committee, where its fiscal impact is being considered. The fate of the bill hangs in the balance, as it needs to come out of suspense by Thursday to move forward. A report from September 2021 highlighted that California lags behind many other states in terms of high schools offering computer science courses. Only 42% of high schools in California offered computer science during the 2018-19 school year, with just 5% of the state’s 1.9 million students enrolling in such courses. Access to computer science education varied based on factors such as socioeconomic status, racial demographics, and geographic location of schools.
The disparities in computer science access are evident, with only 31% of schools serving low-income students offering the course compared to 69% of high-income schools. In states like Nevada, where a policy requiring schools to offer computer science is in place, about 96% of schools provide the course. The need for a computer science requirement in California is crucial to close equity gaps and ensure that every student has access to this foundational knowledge of technology.
Closing Equity Gaps: The Need for a Computer Science Requirement
Despite a slight increase in the percentage of schools offering computer science courses in California, the state still lags behind the national average. As of 2023, 45% of high schools in California offer computer science courses, compared to the national average of 57.5%. Disparities persist among student groups and schools in certain communities, emphasizing the importance of a mandatory computer science requirement in high schools.
The data from the 2022-23 school year revealed that 55% of high schools in California do not offer any computer science courses. Additionally, only 27% of rural schools provide the course, compared to 50% of urban schools and 52% of suburban schools. The proposed legislation aims to bring all schools to a baseline of offering computer science courses, ensuring that no student is left behind based on their ZIP code or background.
The definition of computer science, as outlined in AB 2097, encompasses the study of computers and algorithmic processes, including their principles, implementation, and impact on society. The bill emphasizes the importance of students going beyond using technology to understanding how and why these technologies work. Computer science education equips students with the skills to meaningfully engage in a digitally driven world, enhancing their digital literacy, critical thinking, and problem-solving abilities.
The Potential Impact of Computer Science Education
Computer science education has far-reaching implications across various industries and sectors. From education to entertainment, agriculture to medicine, and social justice to art, the skills acquired through computer science courses are applicable in diverse fields. For instance, students may develop an app to increase access to healthcare services or explore the ethical implications of data privacy. The foundational understanding of technology gained through computer science courses prepares students to navigate a tech-driven society and contribute meaningfully to their communities.
The increasing demand for digital skills in the job market underscores the importance of computer science education. According to a 2020 analysis by the Brookings Institution, jobs requiring medium and high levels of digital skills have increased over the past two decades, while jobs requiring low-level skills have decreased. A 2023 report from the National Skills Coalition revealed that 92% of jobs now require digital skills, highlighting the essential role of computer science education in preparing students for future career opportunities.
In California alone, there are an average of 45,245 open computing jobs each month, with an average salary of $153,544. However, the lack of access to computer science education hinders students from pursuing these lucrative opportunities in their home state. Mary Nicely, the state’s chief deputy superintendent of public instruction, emphasized the need to provide students with the skills and knowledge required to access these jobs and contribute to the state’s economy.
The Benefits of Computer Science Education
Computer science courses offer students a fundamental understanding of technology, encompassing concepts such as artificial intelligence, web design and development, graphics, computer programming, robotics, cybersecurity, and problem-solving. These skills are essential for students to thrive in a tech-centric world and explore diverse career paths. Despite the challenges of implementing computer science education in underserved communities, the benefits far outweigh the obstacles.
In counties like Colusa, Mariposa, Modoc, San Benito, and Sierra, where students had no access to computer science courses, the implementation of AB 2097 would open doors to new opportunities. Additionally, the report highlighted that only 34% of schools with a high proportion of Black, Indigenous, Latino, and Pacific Islander students offered computer science courses, underscoring the need for equitable access to this critical field of study.
The Importance of Meeting Students Where They Are
One of the key principles of computer science education is meeting students where they are and providing them with the necessary support to succeed. While some opponents of the bill argue that students need prerequisite courses on basic digital skills to excel in computer science classes, educators like Amy Pezzoni emphasize the importance of tailoring instruction to meet individual student needs.
Pezzoni, a computer science teacher in Modesto City Schools, believes in empowering students to apply their skills in meaningful ways. By understanding students’ motivations and aspirations, educators can create a supportive learning environment that encourages exploration and growth. Pezzoni’s experience in teaching computer science in low-income schools demonstrates that with the right resources and support, students can excel in this field and pursue diverse career paths.
The Path to Equitable Computer Science Education
The implementation of Assembly Bill 2097 poses challenges in terms of funding and resources. While the exact cost of implementing the bill is unknown, it could range from millions to tens of millions of dollars annually. The Department of Finance has expressed concerns about the ongoing funding required for the bill, estimating a cost of $50 million to $73 million from Proposition 98.
Despite the financial implications, California has made significant investments in professional development and certification for computer science teachers. The state updated credentialing guidelines in 2016 to allow teachers in other disciplines to pursue a computer science supplementary authorization, preparing them to teach the course effectively. By prioritizing teacher training and curriculum development, California aims to ensure that every student has access to high-quality computer science education.
The Future of Computer Science Education in California
While Assembly Bill 2097 does not currently mandate computer science as a graduation requirement, Assemblymember Marc Berman believes that it should be an eventual goal for all students. The bill focuses on increasing access to computer science education in public high schools, laying the groundwork for future initiatives to make the course a graduation requirement.
As California continues to evolve in response to changing economic and technological landscapes, the importance of computer science education cannot be overstated. By equipping students with the skills and knowledge needed to thrive in a digital world, the state can foster innovation, creativity, and economic growth. The passage of AB 2097 would mark a significant step towards ensuring that every student in California has access to high-quality computer science education, regardless of their background or location.
